The best lakes for ice fishing near Eagle River, WI are the ones where the DNR’s nets and its abundance ratings agree.

On the Eagle River Chain that points to Catfish for walleye and pike, Yellow Birch and Lynx for perch numbers, and Scattering Rice and Otter for crappie that clear 10 inches. Upstream on the Three Lakes Chain, Island and Laurel carry the DNR’s “abundant” walleye rating too.

Northwoods Voyageur · Lake Forest Resort Unit 102, independently owned.

This post is the lake-by-lake pick list. For ice safety, licenses and local help in one place, our ice fishing guide to the Chain is the pillar page; read it first if this is your first winter here.

Late-January ice, a wood fire after: check Jan 22-24, 2027 →

We picked that weekend for a reason: in a typical winter, area lakes carry 12 to 14 inches by late January, and the walleye bite on the Chain’s weed edges is at its most predictable.

The best lakes for ice fishing near Eagle River, WI, side by side

Every Wisconsin lake gets a DNR rating per species: abundant, common or present. The DNR also netted eight Chain lakes in spring 2025 and counted fish per acre. Ratings tell you what a lake has held over time; the 2025 numbers tell you what was there last spring. Neither tells you where fish sit on a January afternoon.

Lake Acres Max depth Walleye rating Adult walleye per acre (2025) Public landing
Catfish 1,012 30 ft Abundant 7.2 DNR: 1
Cranberry 924 23 ft Abundant 4.2 DNR: 1
Eagle 575 34 ft Abundant 7.2 DNR: 1
Duck 106 20 ft Abundant 1.3 None listed
Yellow Birch 192 23 ft Common 7.9 DNR: 1
Otter 174 30 ft Common 7.2 None listed
Lynx 31 20 ft Common 10.3 DNR: 1
Scattering Rice 263 17 ft Common 1.6 DNR: 1; ERCLA: no
Voyageur 143 14 ft Common not netted ERCLA: yes
Island (Three Lakes) 305 26 ft Abundant not netted Not stated
Laurel (Three Lakes) 249 27 ft Abundant not netted DNR: 1

Two lakes break the pattern, and they’re worth knowing. Lynx is rated only “common,” yet it had the densest walleye on the Chain in 2025. Duck is rated “abundant,” yet it had the thinnest. When the two disagree, we trust the recent netting for numbers and treat the rating as history.

Catfish Lake: where we’d drill the first hole

If we had one Saturday on the ice, it would start on Catfish. The DNR put its adult walleye population at about 7,236 fish in 2025, the biggest single estimate on the Chain, and the length chart peaks near 12 inches. That suits the Chain’s rule, which lets you keep walleye under 14 inches.

Catfish also had the best northern pike catch rate in the 2025 netting, with a 36-inch fish, and more than 70 percent of Chain pike were 21 inches or longer.

Set a tip-up with a large shiner in about 10 feet for pike in the afternoon. For walleye, local guides work weed edges and transition breaks at 10 to 14 feet with medium shiners or sucker minnows, and the evening is best.

Eagle Lake: deep water and a marked crossing

At 34 feet, Eagle is the deepest lake on the Chain, and the DNR rates its walleye abundant with 7.2 adults per acre in 2025. The fish run small, though: only 17 percent of adults were 15 inches or longer. Plan on a bucket of 11- to 13-inch eaters rather than a wall fish.

Eagle has one winter advantage over Catfish. Local businesses mark its lake trail with safety lights once the ice is checked, and they did so all of 2025-26. Marked does not mean safe for walking anywhere you like; it means one route has been checked.

Living room with a brick fireplace and sliding doors opening toward the lake through the trees
The living room at Unit 102 looks out toward the lake.

Yellow Birch and Lynx: perch numbers on the river end

For a kid’s first ice trip, numbers matter more than size. Yellow Birch and Lynx had the Chain’s highest perch catch rates in 2025, out of a range that ran from 65.9 to 383.8 perch per net-night. Only 12 to 29 percent of Chain perch were 8 inches or longer, so bring a bucket and expect to sort.

Lynx is tiny at 31 acres, but it held 10.3 adult walleye per acre, and 55 percent of them were 15 inches or longer.

Both lakes are “complex-riverine” in DNR terms, which means the Eagle River runs through them. That current is the reason to stay in the bays and away from where the river enters and leaves. Fish perch at 15 to 20 feet.

Scattering Rice and Otter: crappie that clear 10 inches

Crappie are the size story on this Chain. In 2025, 66 percent of Scattering Rice crappie and 65 percent of Otter crappie were 10 inches or longer, and Catfish was close at 57 percent. They hold deep, especially early and late in the season, so a flasher earns its spot in the sled.

Scattering Rice is also the lake for one heavy walleye instead of a limit. It had only 1.6 adults per acre, but 87 percent were 15 inches or longer. That’s mostly catch-and-release under the Chain’s slot rule, and still a good afternoon.

Cranberry and Duck: big water, fewer fish

Cranberry is the second-biggest lake on the Chain at 924 acres. The DNR estimated 4,013 adult walleye there in 2025, about 4.2 per acre, and its perch catch rate ranked above the 90th percentile for its lake class. It sits at the upstream end near the Burnt Rollways channel, so keep well back from the river mouth.

Duck is the outlier. Rated abundant, netted at 1.3 adults per acre, with 58 percent of them 15 inches or longer. Neither source lists a public landing. We’d skip it for a first trip.

Voyageur Lake: the one outside our door

Unit 102 sits on Voyageur, 143 acres and 14 feet at its deepest, between Catfish and Eagle. The DNR rates its northern pike “common,” a step up from the “present” rating pike get on the rest of the Chain, and its walleye common too. It was not part of the 2025 netting.

We haven’t confirmed that guests can get onto Voyageur’s ice from resort property, so we don’t send anyone out that way. Plan on a public access you’ve checked, and enjoy the lake from the balcony, where it’s in view all winter.

The rules that shape a Chain ice trip

From the DNR’s 2026 lookup for the Eagle Chain, seasons running to March 7, 2027:

Species Daily bag Size rule
Walleye 3 No minimum; 14 to 18 inches go back; only 1 over 18
Northern pike 5 No minimum
Panfish (open all year) 25 total No minimum
Musky Closed Open water only, closed December 31

Anyone 16 or older needs a Wisconsin fishing license. Look up your exact lake in the DNR regulations lookup before you keep anything. Three lines per angler is the limit; our ice fishing gear list for the Chain shows how to rig two tip-ups and a jig rod inside it.

Ice first, lake second

Pick the lake at home. Pick the spot after a phone call. The DNR doesn’t monitor local ice, and on a river chain the thin spots sit exactly where lakes connect.

What to ask:

  1. Who’s on the lake you want?
  2. Where are they getting on?
  3. Is there open water near the river mouth?

Our ice safety guide for the Eagle River Chain maps the hazards lake by lake, and the full DNR self-rescue steps are on the DNR ice safety page.

Ice fishing from Unit 102

The condo is set up for a fishing weekend where the gear comes back wet:

  • Washer and dryer in the unit for soaked base layers and mittens.
  • Wood-burning fireplace with a brick surround for the hour after you come off the ice. Firewood isn’t stocked, so grab a bundle in town.
  • Trailer parking on site, close to the condo, for a sled or ATV trailer.
  • Corridor 10 ride-out. Guests ride right out of the resort to Corridor 10 (the Sno-Eagles’ Trail 10E) along Hwy 70, about half a mile south, if part of your group came to ride.
  • Sleeps 6: king suite with a lake-view balcony, a queen plus a twin-over-twin bunk in bedroom 2, and a queen pull-out sofa, with two full baths.

For the week-by-week season outlook, see the ice fishing season preview, and for how the lakes lock up, read when the Eagle River Chain freezes.

Two nights on the Chain in February: check Feb 5-7, 2027 → or see the condo first.